Nuisance - Elements

When your property use is unreasonably interfered with, it may be considered a nuisance.

To win a nuisance case in court, you must prove these legal elements:

  1. Property Right: You owned, leased, occupied, or controlled the property.
  2. Harmful Condition: The Defendant created a condition causing harm.
  3. Conduct: The Defendant’s conduct was intentional, unreasonable, negligent, or reckless.
  4. Interference: The harmful condition seriously affected your property's use or enjoyment.
  5. Unreasonableness: An ordinary person would be annoyed by the Defendant’s conduct.
  6. Lack of Consent: You did not consent to the Defendant’s conduct.
  7. Damages: You were harmed, the Defendant’s conduct caused harm, and the harm outweighed the public benefit.

Example

Your neighbor's loud, late-night parties have been disrupting your peace and causing you sleepless nights. The excessive noise has even made you late for work, affecting your daily routine and causing financial damages.

  1. Property Right: 02/02/2022, you moved into the property.
  2. Harmful Condition: 05/30/2022, neighbor's late-night loud music.
  3. Conduct: 05/25/2022, 05/27/2022, and 05/30/2022, frequent loud music at late-night parties.
  4. Interference: 05/30/2022, loud music kept you up until 3AM and caused tardiness at work.
  5. Unreasonableness: 06/01/2022, city's quiet hours from 10PM to 6AM, affecting sleep around 3AM.
  6. Lack of Consent: 05/30/2022, requested neighbor to end party at 11PM.
  7. Damages:
    1. 06/10/2022, $1,000 on soundproof windows.
    2. 06/11/2022, $50 on earplugs and white noise machine.
    3. 05/31/2022, lost wages ($100 total) due to lateness.
    4. Seeking $1,150 total in damages.

Learn more about Nuisance cases.

🛈 Note that different states may have different laws about causes of actions and elements. This article is based on California law, please review your state law.

Still need help? Contact Us Contact Us